PART 3: CHILDREN'S OUTCOMES - HEALTH

Abuse and Neglect

Child abuse and neglect both undermine child well-being in childhood and increase vulnerability to a wide range of problems in later life 34 , such as mental health problems, low self-esteem and difficulties with interpersonal relationships, including parenting 35 36

Measure

The number of children who had an initial assessment for child welfare and protection concerns.

Key findings

  • In 2006, 12,520 children had an initial assessment for a child welfare and protection concern following a report to the Social Work Department in the Health Service Executive (HSE). This equates to an overall rate of 120.8 children per 10,000 (see Table 58).
  • The lowest number of assessments were carried out in HSE Dublin North-East (1,868) and the highest number of assessments in HSE Dublin Mid-Leinster (4,952).

Table 58: Number of reported cases that went to initial assessment for child welfare and protection concerns, by HSE Region (2006)

HSE Region Total
Dublin Mid-Leinster 4,952
Dublin North-East 1,868
West 3,490
South 2,210
State 12,520
Rate per 10,000 120.8

Source: Childcare Interim Dataset, HSE

Differences by type of concern

  • The highest number of reported cases that went to initial assessment for child welfare and protection concerns was for welfare cases (6,221 or 49.7%) and the lowest number was for cases of emotional abuse (1,100 or 8.8%) (see Table 59 and Figure 22).

Table 59: Number of reported cases that went to initial assessment for child welfare and protection concerns, by type of concern and HSE Region (2006)

HSE Region Welfare Physical abuse Sexual abuse Emotional abuse Neglect Total
Dublin Mid-Leinster 2,302 622 650 458 920 4,952
Dublin North-East 791 262 251 91 473 1,868
West 1,983 238 342 326 601 3,490
South 1,145 169 252 225 419 2,210
State 6,221 1,291 1,495 1,100 2,413 12,520
Rate per 10,000 60.0 12.5 14.4 10.6 23.3 120.8

Source:Childcare Interim Dataset, HSE

Figure 22: Percentage of reported cases that went to initial assessment for child welfare
and protection concerns, by type of concern (2006)

fig22

Source: Childcare Interim Dataset, HSE

Technical notes
Some caution should be adopted when comparing across HSE Regions because of differences in the way in which cases are recorded. Work is currently taking place on the development of consistent approaches across the HSE Regions.

The number of children who had an initial assessment for child welfare and protection concerns is an important measure of the incidence of child abuse and neglect in Ireland. It should be noted, however, that these rates are affected by a number of factors other than the actual incidence of abuse and neglect, and some caution is thus required in drawing conclusions concerning the overall prevalence of abuse and neglect for the following reasons. First, some cases of abuse and neglect are never reported. Secondly, some incidents are reported more than once and several reports may relate to a single family. Thirdly, reports tend to increase for reasons unrelated to the actual prevalence of abuse and neglect, such as a highly publicised case or public awareness campaign.

Next

34 Hooper, C.A. (2002) 'Maltreatment of Children'. In: J. Bradshaw (ed.), The Well-Being of Children in the UK. York: Save the Children, pp. 103-21.

35 Ferguson, H. and McNamara, T. (eds.) (1996) Protecting Irish Children: Investigation, Protection and Welfare. Dublin: Institute of Public Administration.

36 Bifulco, A. and Moran, P. (1998) Wednesday's Child: Research into women's experience of neglect and abuse in childhood, and adult depression. London: Routledge Press.